Bruegel’s The Fight Between Carnival and Lent

Melvyn Bragg and guests discuss Pieter Bruegel the Elder’s painting of 1559, ‘The Fight Between Carnival And Lent’. Created in Antwerp at a time of religious tension between Catholics and Protestants, the painting is rich in detail and seems ripe for interpretation. But Bruegel is notoriously difficult to interpret. His art seems to reject the preoccupations of the Italian Renaissance, drawing instead on techniques associated with the new technology of the 16th century, print. Was Bruegel using his art to comment on the controversies of his day? If so, what comment was he making?

→ Listen on BBC Sounds website

Guests

• Louise Milne No other episodes
  Lecturer in Visual Culture in the School of Art at the University of Edinburgh and Edinburgh Napier University
• Jeanne Nuechterlein No other episodes
  Senior Lecturer in the Department of History of Art, University of York
• Miri Rubin 12 episodes
  Professor of Medieval and Early Modern History and Head of the School of History at Queen Mary, University of London

Reading list

• Bruegel
  Walter S. Gibson (Thames & Hudson, 1985) Google Books →
• Pieter Bruegel and the Art of Laughter
  Walter S. Gibson (University of California Press, 2006) Google Books →
• Pieter Bruegel the Elder, c.1525-1569: Peasants, Fools and Demons
  Rose-Marie Hagen and Rainer Hagen (Benedikt Taschen, 1994) Google Books →
• Bruegel: The Complete Works
  Rose-Marie Hagen and Rainer Hagen (Taschen, 2000) Google Books →
• Carnivals and Dreams: Pieter Bruegel and the History of the Imagination
  Louise Milne (Mutus Liber, 2011) Google Books →
• Popular Culture and Popular Movements in Reformation Germany
  R. W. Scribner (Hambledon Press, 1987) Google Books →

Related episodes

• The Sistine Chapel
  
  31 Mar, 2022 700 Arts
• Paganism in the Renaissance
  
  16 Jun, 2005 940 History of Europe
• William Morris
  
  5 Jul, 2018 700 Arts
• Albrecht Dürer
  
  12 Nov, 2020 700 Arts
• The School of Athens
  
  26 Mar, 2009 750 Painting
• The Baroque Movement
  
  20 Nov, 2008 700 Arts
• The Thirty Years War
  
  6 Dec, 2018 940 History of Europe
• The Sack of Rome 1527
  
  22 Feb, 2024 940 History of Europe
• Erasmus
  
  9 Feb, 2012 270 History of Christianity
• The Siege of Munster
  
  5 Nov, 2009 270 History of Christianity

Experimental. For more related episodes, visit the visual explorer.

---

Programme ID: b04xrv9n

Episode page: bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04xrv9n

Auto-category: 759.9492 (Bruegel, Pieter, approximately 1525-1569)

Hello (First sentence from this episode)

Hello, I'm looking at a painting which is looking down on a busy square with crowds of people dressed in a late medieval costume.